omgwutlulz review criteria

Spelling and Grammar (25)
-can be lenient if non-English speaker but otherwise, I'll be on your case with commas, wrong use of words, etc.
Poster, if one is used. (5)
-does the poster(s) express the story's main idea(s)?
-does the poster add interest to the story?
- is the story properly portrayed through the poster?
Title (5)
-is your title too long?
-is your title creative?
-is your title interesting?
Creativity/Originality/Plot (30)
-how original is the storyline?
-if used before, how does this variation of the storyline differ from others?
-what makes your story stand out from the others; what makes it so interesting?
-does your storyline constantly change; does it fail to be consistent?
Characters (25)
-are your characters constant?
-do the characters make sudden, abrupt change sin personality without any explanation?
-can you properly display emotions/feelings with your characters in different situations?
Effects of Story (20)
-does your story leave readers wanting more?
-does your story grab readers?
-what type of emotion does the story leave readers with?

SoneShawolLuvsMe review criteria

Title (-/5) 

Appearance (-/5)

Description/Foreword (-/10) 

Characters (-/20)

Writing Style (-/15)

Flow (-/10)

Plot (-/15)

Basic Grammar/Spelling (-/15)

Enjoyment (-/20)

(-/115)

A *- 100 - 115

A - 85 - 100

B - 70 - 85

C - 55 - 70

D - 40 - 55

E - 30 - 40

F - 20 - 30

U - 0 - 20

KimSuyun14 review criteria

KimSuyun14 review criteria

Title __/10
-Does the title grab the reader's attention?
Plot/Storyline __/10
-Is the plot/storyline interesting and keeps the reader's interest?
Characters __/10
-Are the characters unique and original?
Originality __/10
-Is the plot obviously made by the author, or based off of something else?
Pictures __/5
-Are the pictures interesting and relate to the chapter/story?
Grammar/spelling __/10
-Is the spelling and grammar correct and accurate?
Overall enjoyment __/15
-Is the story enjoyable, fun and interesting throughout the whole story?
Flow/pace __/5
-Does it feel like the author rushed the chapter? Or is it carefully thought out?
Style __/10
-Is the story set into POV's? Or is it just from first person POV?
Description/Foreword __/10
-Does the Description catch attention? Does it urge the reader to read more?
Views __/5
-Is there a bunch of views in just a few chapters? Or is there a bunch of chapters with just a few views?

Total: 100

sweetieheart2 review criteria

sweetieheart2 Review Criteria

Title: /5
(Is your title appealing? Does it relate to your story?)

Description/Foreword: /10
(Does it draw readers in? Is everything relevant?)

Characterization: /20
(Are your characters original and well-developed?)

Plot/Originality: /20
(Is your plot interesting, unique and original?)

Mechanics: /20
(Grammar, spelling, punctuation etc.) <-- I will cut down to the core with this one.

Flow/Pace and Style: /10
(Does your story flow well and does it move at an appropriate pace? How is your writing style?)

Appearance/Layout (fonts, posters etc.): /5
(Does the poster reflect your fic appropriately? Is the layout of your story suitable for readers’ eyes?) <-- I will not judge “how good the poster is”, as it is irrelevant to the actual fic.

Overall enjoyment: /10
(Is the fic enjoyable as a whole?)

Total: 100

03dreamer15 review criteria

03dreamer15 Review Criteria

1.Poster (10)

- is the poster beautifully made? can it be clearly seen as a visual aid?

2. Title (10)

-did it grab the attention of the readers? was that the reason for readers to click the story?

3. Creativity (20)

-is the story plot interesting?

4. Spelling & Grammar (15)

-(this is self-explanatory)

5. Consistency of story & characters to plot (15)

-was the story and the characters true to the plot, or still connected to the plot?

6. Writing style (15)

-how the story was written

7. Reader Impact (15)

-can the readers enjoy the fanfic as a whole? can they feel the story?

Total: 100